Case overview
Ghana High Court Case
JUDGEMENT
23rd October, 1959. In the High Court of Justice, Ghana. Eastern Judicial Division (Lands Division) held at Victoriaborg, Accra on Friday the 23rd of October, 1959, before '''Ollenu J.''' <u>Land Appeal No.164/1958</u> '''Mallam Jibo'''........ Plaintiff-Appellant versus '''1. Ampeah 2. Odikro Kwaku Frempong'''...... Defendants-Respondents. <u>JUDGEMENT:</u> These proceedings have come from the New Juaben Native Court “A”, Koforidua. The record of the proceedings of the 24th day of October, 1958, has turned out to be very misleading; but for certain subsequent proceedings taken before the Government Agent on the 10th of November, 1958, this Court would have been led to assume that the proceedings in the Native Court on the 24th October, 1958, the day on which Judgment was delivered by Native Court, truly represented what really transpired on that day. The subsequent proceedings taken before the Government Agent have revealed that on the said 24th October, 1958, the President of the Native Court delivered a decision which was in favour of dismissing the Plaintiff's case; but immediately he concluded delivering his said decision and was about to adjourn the Court, the other two members who constituted the Court with him indicated that they disagreed with his said decision and wanted the Court to continue while they delivered their own decision. They then proceeded to do so; while those two members of the Court were delivering their said decision, the Defendant and Co-Defendant left the Court either upon their own initiative or upon the directions of the President. The decision delivered by those two other members of the Court was in favour of allowing the Plaintiff's claim. The Registrar of the Court did not record the decision so delivered by the two members; therefore those members procured a Letter Writer who wrote their decisions down, they signed them and sent copies to Government Agent, the Clerk of the Local Council, and the Registrar of the Native Court. As a result of the copies of the said decisions sent to him, the Government Agent, with the consent of the parties purported to review the proceedings and therefore ordered that the decision delivered by the said two members of the Native Court be ignored, and the decision delivered by the President be recorded as the Judgment of the Native Court. The jurisdiction of the Government Agent to review a decision of a Native Court is given in part 10 of the Native Court Ordinance, Cap 95, which covers sections 59 to 66 of the Ordinance Section 63 provides that:
“The powers granted to the Government Agent under this part shall not be exercisable in respect of a land cause other than in respect of costs.” Therefore the suit herein being a land cause, the Government Agent had no jurisdiction to review it as he purported to do, nor could the consent of the parties confer such jurisdiction upon him; his purported review is consequently null and void. Section 7 of the Native Court Ordinance Cap.98 lays it down that when members of the Native Court disagree the opinion of the majority shall be the Judgment of the Court. By virtue of that section, once the two members of the Native Court disagreed with the President, it became obligatory upon the Registrar under the said section of the Ordinance and Regulation 41 of the Procedure Regulations made under the said Ordinance to record the decision of those two members as the Judgment of the Court; that decision would be Judgment all the same even if the President refused to sign it as required by Regulation 41 aforesaid.Therefore even if the Government Agent had jurisdiction to review the case, he erred in directing the Registrar contrary to section 7, to enter the minority opinion of the President as the Judgment of the Court.In this respect this case is on all fours with the case of MANKATA versus OKORLI 1 W.A.L.R. 169 (W.A.C.A) I hold therefore that the Judgment of the Native Court is the Judgment delivered in favour of the Plaintiff by the two members. Now although the Defendants have not appealed against the decision of the Native Court as they should, I formed the opinion that once the Court is properly seized of the whole case the Defendants are entitled to argue the case on the merits as if they had appealed. In arguing the appeal it was submitted on behalf of the Defendants that firstly the Plaintiff has no locus standi because he is not the head of the inhabitants of the Hansa Zongo of Suhien to whom the land he claims was granted; secondly the Plaintiff is not the successor to the person from whom he claims; thirdly the particular place of land in question which the Plaintiff instituted the action is outside the area granted to the Hansa Community some 50 years or so ago by the Omanhene of New Juaben and his elders including the Odikro of Suhien, predecessor of the Co-Defendant and his elders; and fourthly that the land was subject to a sale or absolute alienation to the Defendant as one of the grantees and/or portions of it to any one else as he liked. On the first question, it is true that the Plaintiff did not sue expressly for himself and as representative of the head and members of the Hansa Community of Suhien. But the headman of the zongo or Hansa Community gave evidence in support of his claim.In those circumstances I am bound to hold, as did Jackson J. in his judgment delivered on the 10th October, 1951, in suit entitled Mallam Jibo v. (the same person as the plaintiff herein ) vs: Abina Dabadwa, a case in which the Co-Defendant in this
case gave evidence in support of the Plaintiff in a claim he made in respect of land which included the land now in dispute, and based upon the same root of title as successor to Mumuni. In my opinion the Co-Defendant is estopped by his conduct in supporting the Plaintiff's claim in the former suit from now disputing that the Plaintiff is successor to Mumuni. As to the identity of the land now in dispute with that in the former suit, the evidence on the record leaves no room for doubt that land now in dispute is a small portion of larger area, subject matter of the previous suit. On the counter-claim of the Co-Defendant that he was entitled to alienate this portion of the land, it is interesting to point out that upon the evidence on record, including that of the Co-Defendant himself, once the Plaintiff's predecessors in title had granted possessory title in the land to the Hansa Community, he has no right to grant any portion of that land subject matter of the grant to any one else without the previous consent of the owner of the possessory title in the land. Moreover the plot of land in dispute is not an unoccupied land, but land on which stands a house of the Plaintiff's predecessor, and the Plaintiff still has that possessory title vested in him since it is not shown that he has abandoned his said title to the land; the removal of the roof of his predecessor's buildings on the land is not conclusive evidence of abandonment of his possessory title. The Defendant went upon the land as a grantee of the Co-Defendant, since it is shown that his grantor cannot deny the title of the Plaintiff and is not entitled to interfere with the Plaintiff's possession and occupation of the land, the Defendant committed a wrong by entering upon the land and commencing to build thereon without the leave and licence of the Plaintiff. In the circumstances the majority decision of the Native Court is a sound one and should not be interfered with. That Judgment should be formally entered for the Plaintiff in the following terms: There will be Judgment for Plaintiff for declaration of his possessory title to the land in dispute and for an Order for recovery of possession. The appeal is allowed, the Plaintiff will have his costs in this Court fixed at £20. 12/-, including 10 guineas Counsel's Costs, and all his costs both in the Native Court and in the proceedings before the Government Agent to be taxed. Native Court to carry out. Counsel: Puplampu for the Plaintiff-Appellant. Bredu Pabi for the Defendants-Respondents.
